I'm going to preface this by saying I'm pretty stoked for the new Star Wars Squadrons game, the small scale 5v5 battles sound fun and having ships of different classes with different roles is interesting.
Which made me think "Why can't Star Trek do this?"
Well, that made me think how ships in Star Trek games typically just follow the approach of "Slower = More Health and More Weapons", there isn't much to separate out the different classes, so there is little reason to pick a DD over a CA unless its personal preference.
Well, I don't think it would take much to change this, by rebalancing ships, and limiting options so each available class has its own place to shine.
So I am going to outline a small set of ship classes that could work with a Star Trek Multiplayer Focused Game/Mod:
**All Ships**
Primary Weapon - Phasers or Disruptors
**Frigates**
Fastest Ship/Lowest Health
Secondary Weapon - Missiles
Best Seeking/Worst Damage
**Destroyer**
Medium Speed/Medium Health
Secondary Weapon - Heavy Torpedoes
Worst or No Tracking/Most Damage
**Light Cruiser**
*Support Role*
Slow Speed/High Health
Secondary Weapon - Tractor Beam Weapon or none, low damage
Can Tractor Beam
Can Use Marines
?Can Repair Team Mates?
?Can Rearm Team Mates?
**Heavy Cruiser**
*Limited to 1 per team*
Slowest Speed/Highest Health
Secondary Weapon - Torpedoes
Medium Tracking/Medium Damage
Perhaps give passive buffs to team mates when close enough
Perhaps the objective is to take out the other team's Heavy Cruiser
I think a lot of this could be done in KA, except for the Ammo Refil/Health Healing/AoE Effects.
But we could remove some of the standard ship features like Tractor Beams, Transporters, ECM and place them only on Support ships, and have the other classes have enough varied weaponry to make each class feel unique.
Of course, this isn't something that would work without the game widely available and easy to connect to each other for Multiplayer, its more or less just proof of concept. I could make this mod for KA, but I don't see anyone being able to play it, especially if the goal is 5v5 Battles.